Dear Friends of Developmental Philosophy,
At the November meeting of our monthly Zoom group, I interviewed Paul VanderKlay, founder of the Estuary movement.
Together with John Vandonk, Paul started Estuary, a movement of in-person gatherings where people with very different views come together to talk face to face. It grew out of the online community around his YouTube channel, and local Estuary groups now meet in cities across the US and abroad. The movement has also grown into regional conferences, such as Midwestuary near Chicago and Southeastuary in North Carolina.
Paul tells how a YouTube channel that started as response videos to Jordan Peterson grew into this movement, walks through the simple Estuary conversation protocol, and explains why disagreement among friends builds trust rather than breaking it. Steve then joins the conversation, followed by questions from the group.
I invited Paul because Estuary is where I see cultural evolution happening in real time. In the Q&A, a member of the group named the developmental connection: communities like this are rebuilding what postmodernism knocked out.
Paul’s YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/@PaulVanderKlay
Learn more about Estuary: https://www.estuaryhub.com/
Something to reflect on as you watch: where have you seen a disagreement build trust instead of breaking it?
Watch the full conversation and Q&A here: https://youtu.be/ATdH0YEQBys
Jump to any section:
– 2:14 How response videos to Jordan Peterson became a movement
– 8:44 The Estuary protocol: person, pitch, point, play
– 21:30 “The coin of the realm is trust”
– 24:09 Why pushing an agenda costs you status
– 27:56 The big rat, the little rat, and why play needs trust
– 34:36 “Fast growth is not human growth”
– 39:44 C.S. Lewis, Owen Barfield, and why truth needs friction
– 43:00 After four years, a calm conversation about Trump
– 48:07 Where is Christianity headed?
– 58:55 Q&A: can Christianity rest on mythological truth?
– 1:03:24 Q&A: what to build after the conversation (“up your reps”)
Next month, on Wednesday, December 9, Jeff Salzman joins us. Click here to join Steve McIntosh’s monthly Zoom group and to receive Zoom instructions:
https://www.developmentalphilosophy.org/join-steve-mcintoshs-monthly-zoom-group/




